Trade-In/Financing

How to Trade with Negative Equity

You’re ready for a different vehicle, but you still owe more on your current one than it’s worth. That doesn’t lock you in. It does mean the gap has to go somewhere, and where it goes decides how much your next loan costs.

Quick answer

Can I trade in a car if I owe more than it’s worth?

Yes. When you owe more on your loan than the car is worth, the difference is called negative equity, and you can still trade the car in. The dealership pays off your current lender as part of the deal. The difference then has to be covered: you pay it in cash, roll it into the loan on your next vehicle if a lender approves it, or wait and pay your loan down first.

“Underwater” and “upside down” mean the same thing. The question isn’t whether you can trade. It’s which way of handling the gap leaves you in the best shape for your next loan.

Step One: Find Your Real Number

Negative equity is simple math: your loan payoff minus your car’s trade-in value. The catch is using the right two numbers.

Your Payoff Amount

Ask your lender for a payoff quote. The CFPB notes it can differ from the balance on your statement because of how interest is calculated and any fees still owed.

Your Trade-In Value

Start with an online estimate, then get a written appraisal. A KBB estimate and a dealer offer can differ, and the offer is the number that counts.

The Difference

Payoff minus trade-in value. If your payoff is $18,000 and your car is worth $15,000, your negative equity is $3,000.

Why the Appraisal Matters Here

Every dollar of trade-in value shrinks the gap. Bring service records and every key, and compare written offers before you decide how to handle the balance.

What Rolling Over Negative Equity Means

Rolling over means the leftover balance from your current loan is added to the loan for your next vehicle. It’s the most common way people handle the gap, and the most important one to understand before you sign.

Here’s a hypothetical example using round numbers, before taxes, fees and any down payment:

Line ItemAmount
Price of the vehicle you’re buying$32,000
Trade-in value credited−$15,000
Payoff on your current loan+$18,000
Amount to finance$35,000
Compared with the vehicle’s price$3,000 more than the vehicle costs

Hypothetical numbers for illustration only. Your figures depend on your payoff, appraisal, vehicle price, taxes, fees and approved terms.

In this example you start the new loan owing more than the new vehicle is worth, and you pay interest on that extra $3,000 for the life of the loan. That’s the real cost of rolling over: not a hidden fee, just a bigger loan.

What the CFPB Found

A CFPB study of auto loans from 2018 to 2022 found that 11.6% of loans included negative equity from a prior vehicle. Compared with borrowers who traded in a vehicle with positive equity, those borrowers had:

  • Larger loans for the vehicle’s value: an average loan-to-value ratio of 119.3%, versus 88.9%.
  • Higher payments: an average monthly payment of $626, versus $496.
  • More risk later: a higher likelihood of having the account assigned to repossession within two years.

Your Options When You’re Underwater

No option is right for everyone. The best one depends on how soon you need a different vehicle and how much room your budget has.

Pay the Difference in Cash

Covering the gap at signing means your next loan starts with only the new vehicle in it. If you can do it without draining your savings, it’s the cleanest path.

Roll It Into Your Next Loan

Convenient when you need to change vehicles now. Expect a larger amount financed and more interest, and know that lenders limit how much they’ll finance relative to the vehicle’s value.

Wait and Pay It Down

If your current car still meets your needs, every payment shrinks the gap. Extra principal payments shrink it faster, if your loan allows them.

Lower the Amount You Finance

A larger down payment or a less expensive vehicle reduces how much of your next loan is old debt.

In Georgia, your trade-in value can also lower the title tax on your next vehicle when you trade at a dealership. See Georgia TAVT trade-in tax savings for how that works.

How to Protect Yourself in the Deal

Negative equity is a normal part of many trade-ins. These checks keep it from becoming a surprise:

  • Ask how the balance is handled: Find the negative equity on the paperwork, not just in the conversation.
  • Read “we’ll pay off your loan” carefully: The CFPB advises that if a dealer promises to pay off your negative equity, that amount shouldn’t be added to your new financing.
  • Look past the monthly payment: A longer term can make a bigger loan look affordable. Compare the amount financed and the total cost.
  • Confirm the old loan is closed: The CFPB suggests waiting about a week and then checking with your old lender that the payoff went through.

Frequently Asked Questions

Short answers to the questions we hear most. Still unsure? Our team is happy to help.

Can I trade in a car if I owe more than it’s worth?

Yes. Owing more than your car is worth is called negative equity, and it doesn’t stop you from trading in. The difference still has to be covered: you can pay it in cash, roll it into your next loan if a lender approves it, or wait until you’ve paid the loan down.

What does rolling over negative equity mean?

It means the amount you still owe beyond your car’s trade-in value is added to the loan for your next vehicle. The dealership pays off your old lender, and the leftover balance becomes part of your new loan, so you finance more than the new vehicle costs.

How do I know if I have negative equity?

Get the payoff amount from your lender, which can differ from the balance on your statement, and compare it with your vehicle’s trade-in value. If the payoff is higher, the difference is your negative equity.

Is rolling negative equity into a new loan a bad idea?

It isn’t automatically wrong, but it costs more. The CFPB found that borrowers who financed negative equity had larger loans relative to their vehicle’s value, higher monthly payments and a higher likelihood of repossession than borrowers who didn’t. Paying the gap down first, or covering it with cash, keeps your next loan smaller.

What should I check in the contract?

Ask how the negative equity is being handled and find it in the paperwork. If a dealer says it will pay off your negative equity, the CFPB advises making sure that amount isn’t added to your new financing. After the sale, confirm with your old lender that the loan was paid off.

Find Out Where You Stand

Get your trade valued and talk through the options with the Subaru Newnan finance team before you choose how to handle the balance.

Examples are for illustration only and are not financial advice. Financing is subject to credit approval, and terms vary by lender. Trade-in offers are based on an in-person appraisal and are subject to change.

Menu

Get Directions

705 Newnan Crossing Bypass, Newnan, GA, 30263
Subaru Newnan 33.3788814, -84.7627414.